Skip to main content

SID codes (part 4)

I wanted to call this post "Return of the SID", but there is only so much nerdiness you can squeeze into one topic. But, I am going to talk about SID codes once again, so it is best to first read part 1, part 2 and part 3 about SID codes if you are not familiar with them.

SID codes are inherently tied to CDs, or CD-like media (DVD, Blu-Ray, and so on) and have not been used anywhere else. One thing I wondered: for how many releases in the Discogs database have SID codes been defined when it actually is a different format for which SID codes do not make any sense at all, such as vinyl, or cassettes? So I got the latest Discogs data dump (releases until November 1 2017), adapted my scripts, ran some tests and got quite interesting results:
  • 332 vinyl records
  • 151 cassettes
  • 24 files (digital music files)
  • 13 shellac discs
  • 2 DCC releases
  • 1 VHS release
  • 1 Memory Stick release
  • 1 Edison Disc
Especially the Edison Disc made me chuckle, as it is such an ancient format, and this particular release had been released some 70 years before SID codes were even invented.

With the shellac discs and Edison Disc it was mostly that people picked the wrong option in the drop down box for BaOI, but for most other releases people simply copied from a CD or DVD release (using "copy to draft") and never bothered to either adapt or remove the old data (including tracklisting, catalog numbers, barcodes, and so on). There were also a few releases where there was for example a CD with a vinyl release, but the release was only tagged as "vinyl".

This could have course have been prevented if Discogs would have displayed warnings when people submitted releases by for example giving a warning like "It looks like you are submitting a vinyl release, but you have SID codes, which do not exist for vinyl records.".

It shows  that there is still a lot that can be improved.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

SID codes (part 1)

One thing that I only learned about after using Discogs is the so called Source Identification Code, or SID. These codes were introduced in 1994 to combat piracy and to find out on which machines a CD was made. It was introduced by Philips and adopted by IFPI, and specifications are publicly available which clearly describe the two available SID codes (mastering SID code and mould SID code). Since quite a few months Discogs has two fields available in the " Barcode and Other Identifiers " (BaOI) section: Mould SID code Mastering SID code A few questions immediately popped up in my mind: how many releases don't have a SID field defined when there should be (for example, the free text field indicates it is a SID field)? how many releases have a SID field with values that should not be in the SID field? how many release have a SID field, but a wrong year (as SID codes were only introduced in 1994) how many vinyl releases have a SID code defined (which is impossi...
1 comment
Read more

SPARS codes (part 1)

Let's talk about SPARS codes used on CDs (or CD-like formats). You have most likely seen it used, but maybe don't know its name. The SPARS code is a three letter code indicating if recording, mixing and mastering were analogue or digital. For example they could look like the ones below. There is not a fixed format, so there are other variants as well. Personally I am not paying too much attention to these codes (I simply do not care), but in the classical music world if something was labeled as DDD (so everything digital) companies could ask premium prices. That makes it interesting information to mine and unlock, which is something that Discogs does not allow people to do when searching (yet!) even though it could be a helpful filter. I wanted to see if it can be used as an identifier to tell releases apart (are there similar releases where the only difference is the SPARS code?). SPARS code in Discogs Since a few months SPARS is a separate field in the Discogs ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Country statistics (part 2)

One thing I wondered about: for how many releases is the country field changed? I looked at the two most recent data dumps (covering February and March 2019) and see where they differed. In total 5274 releases "moved". The top 20 moves are: unknown -> US: 454 Germany -> Europe: 319 UK & Europe -> Europe: 217 unknown -> UK: 178 UK -> Europe: 149 Netherlands -> Europe: 147 unknown -> Europe: 139 unknown -> Germany: 120 UK -> US: 118 Europe -> Germany: 84 US -> UK: 79 USA & Canada -> US: 76 US -> Canada: 65 unknown -> France: 64 UK -> UK & Europe: 62 UK & Europe -> UK: 51 France -> Europe: 51 Saudi Arabia -> United Arab Emirates: 49 US -> Europe: 46 unknown -> Japan: 45 When you think about it these all make sense (there was a big consolidation in Europe in the 1980s and releases for multiple countries were made in a single pressing plant) but there are also a few weird changes:...
Post a Comment
Read more